Court rules website cannot ask sexual orientation

Go to: Forums > Technology: Web

There is only one posting to this topic on our Member website and this page runs 7 days behind our Member website. For the full topic click to sign up to OUTeverywhere.

Topic started by Boudie - Spiritual Warrior (saratiddy)

People don't believe me that I'm shy face-2-face, despite being cheeky on Forums. Orginally from the West Country, but been living in Reading for 16 years. I tend to be a bit of a workaholic, but I've learnt my lesson and getting out more and relaxing, thanks to good friends. I am into the arts & crafts, doing & seeing, including theatre, cinema, etc. Joined OUT for both Gay Male & Female friends.

A topic from Technology: Web

saratiddyTue 08/04/08 16:32

Court rules website cannot ask sexual orientation question

A roommate-finding site is prohibited from asking users to disclose their sexual orientation, a US appeals court has ruled.

Arizona-based website Roommates.com came under fire by The Fair Housing Council of San Fernando Valley and the Fair Housing Council of San Diego, who claimed the site violated the Fair Housing Act by demanding users list their sexual orientation as part of their application form.

In the latest dispute over whether anti-discrimination rules apply to the web, the US 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco said the site, which offers more than 100,000 rental listings, was different from sites where people can voluntarily offer or withhold personal information.

In an 8-3 ruling, that partly overturns a lower federal court decision, the panel said that to inquire electronically about sexual orientation would be no different from asking people in person or by telephone if they were black or Jewish before conducting business.

According to OneNews, 9th Circuit Chief Judge Alex Kozinski wrote:

"Not only does Roommate.com ask these questions, it makes answering the discriminatory questions a condition of doing business.

"Websites are complicated enterprises and there will always be close cases where a clever lawyer could argue that something the website operator did encouraged the illegality.

"Such close cases, we believe, must be resolved in favour of immunity.

"Where it is very clear that the website directly participates in developing the alleged illegality, as it is clear here with respect to Roommate's questions, answers and the resulting profile pages, immunity will be lost."

Defence attorney Timothy Alger said in a statement:

"This decision represents a significant departure from what has been settled law across the country.

"We believe the government has no business regulating the selection of roommates or advertising for roommates."

Three judges disagreed with the ruling, stating that the court was creating a dangerous precedent and future confusion for internet firms.

Having contrasted Roommate.com's requests for information with search engines, such as Google, which could allow people to search for terms such as "white roommate", Judge Margaret McKeown wrote:

"The majority's unprecedented expansion of liability for internet service providers threatens to chill the robust development of the internet that Congress envisioned.

"Roommates.com should be afforded no less protection than Google, Yahoo, or other search engines."

Article: www.pinknews.co.uk/news/law/2005-7317.html

Enjoy chatting with our members

Imagine joining a social network of people from all around the country and see how you'll feel a year from today. You're increasing your circle of friends. You're doing more of the stuff you enjoy. You're having a great time meeting new people in your area. You're seeing all the benefits of becoming a member of OUTeverywhere. It still feels great making new friends and every day you're hearing more and more about the stuff that everyone's doing. You're joining in. Now, that was easy, wasn't it?

We make meeting people easy. Click to sign up to OUTeverywhere and get up and do something different!

PLEASE NOTE: Events are listed on this website on behalf of organisers in accordance with the Terms of Membership of OUTeverywhere and only if they have chosen broad publicity when adding their event to the Member Events calendar. As such, events are not necessarily affiliated to or endorsed by OUTeverywhere and may not be organised by the person who has listed the event: the person listing this event may simply be attending an event organised by another person or organisation and may wish to meet other people sharing their interest in the event. The mention or appearance of any person or organisation featured on these pages is not to be taken as any indication of sexual, social or political orientation of such persons or organisations. We cannot guarantee that the information is accurate and recommend that you always seek to contact the organiser directly to confirm full details of any event. Under no circumstances will we be responsible for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on, use or misuse of, the information on this website.

Our Vision | Our Team | Privacy Policy | Identity Theft Protection | Terms of Membership

Chat and Meet People

Enter one or two words to tell us something you enjoy:

Or enter a postcode or the name of a place:

Latest Shout OUT

Broadcast to the gay world with our public Shout OUTs service! Post on our member website or from your mobile phone and raise your profile.

7 Of 7 New Premises- FlatMate24.06 Wanted (timur) from West Brompton in Fulham in United Kingdom shouts OUT: "the sun is trying and its warmer for sure..:)"

Events Calendar

< July 2008 >
S	M	T	W	T	F	S
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17	18	19
20	21	22	23	24	25	26
27	28	29	30	31

This Topic's Tags

Members tag topics with key words to help us find similar topics.

Discover GMEET

Add all your web profiles to the new GMEET.com website profiles directory service. Supports Facebook, YouTube, MySpace, Bebo, LinkedIn and dozens more. For social and business networking, web personals and online dating.